Saving from poverty: A critical review of Individual Development Accounts

an article by Guy Feldman (Tel Aviv University, Israel) published in Critical Social Policy Volume 38 Issue 2 (May 2018)

Abstract

The much-heralded anti-poverty strategy of asset-building has been adopted by many countries across the world. Asset-building programmes are designed to help low-income families achieve long-term financial stability through savings and asset accumulation.

This article offers a comprehensive and critical review of the current state of theory and research on asset-building programmes, with an emphasis on Individual Development Accounts (IDAs) in the United States.

Studies of IDAs have involved quantitative evaluations of the programme, focusing on three key topics:

• the programme’s effects on clients’ savings behaviour,
• its effects on clients’ outlook on life, and
• its long-term impact.

On the basis of a careful review of these findings, it is argued that the claim that IDA programmes and asset-building in general have the potential to reduce poverty is overrated and premature (my bold).

The article builds on theoretical insights regarding the nature of neoliberalism to make sense of the picture portrayed in the research literature.

---