Friday 31 July 2020

In the name of parliamentary sovereignty: conflict between the UK Government and the courts over judicial deference in the case of prisoner voting rights

Helen Hardman
School of Social & Political Sciences, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK

published in British Politics Volume 15 Issue 3 (June 2020)

Abstract
New archival evidence reveals how UK governments, since the 1970s, have been concerned primarily with domestic courts encroaching on executive powers rather than those of the legislature. Alongside the Human Rights Act 1998, a mechanism of judicial ‘deference’ to Parliament evolved to justify courts deferring to an act of Parliament, or to decisions of the legislature, or executive. As this article argues, failure to clarify which of these three is at play has served as a helpful vehicle for Governments to convey the powerful narrative of courts using human rights frameworks to usurp the democratic powers of Parliament as legislature at times of conflict between the courts and the executive. In the prisoner voting debate, actors thus successfully invoked ‘parliamentary sovereignty’ to generate an emotive narrative that the European Court of Human Rights was usurping the powers of ‘Parliament’ when instead the Court, supported by the UK legal community, was challenging the dangerous precedent set by the UK Divisional Court’s deference, in 2001, to the executive. Interview data demonstrate how the 2011 backbench parliamentary debate to flout Strasbourg’s judgements was largely manufactured to curtail the ECHR mechanism which empowers domestic courts to effectively hold the government to account.

Only the abstract freely available BUT, and it's a VERY BIG BUT, Notes and References are given with it here, together with Unattributed interviews and Archival documents.

I've highlighted this to read at the British Library when I finally get there.

Labels:
prisoner_voting_rights, Parliamentary_sovereignty, European_Court_of_Human_Rights,
UK_judiciary, human_rights,


Wednesday 29 July 2020

Change point analysis of historical battle deaths

an article by Brennen T. Fagan, Marina I. Knight, Niall J. MacKay and A. Jamie Wood (University of York, UK) published in Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Statistics in Society Series A Volume 183 Issue 3 (June 2020)

Summary

It has been claimed and disputed that World War II has been followed by a ‘long peace’: an unprecedented decline of war.

We conduct a full change point analysis of well‐documented, publicly available battle deaths data sets, using new techniques that enable the robust detection of changes in the statistical properties of such heavy‐tailed data.

We first test and calibrate these techniques.

We then demonstrate the existence of changes, independent of data presentation, in the early to mid‐19th century, as the Congress of Vienna system moved towards its collapse, in the early to mid‐20th century, bracketing the World Wars, and in the late 20th century, as the world reconfigured around the end of the Cold War.

Our analysis provides a methodology for future investigations and an empirical basis for political and historical discussions.

Full text (PDF 25pp)

Labels:
battle_deaths, change_point_analysis, correlates_of_war, heavy-tailed_data, long_peace, power_law_distribution,

Hazel’s comment:
What I understood of this I found fascinating.


Remedying depletion through social reproduction: a critical engagement with the United Nations’ business and human rights framework

an article by Beth Goldblatt (University of Technology Sydney, Australia) and Shirin M. Rai (University of Warwick, UK) published in European Journal of Politics and Gender Volume 3 Number 2 (June 2020)

Abstract

The growing recognition of unpaid work in international law and the Sustainable Development Goals acknowledges that gendered labour supports the global economy.

This work can have harmful impacts, leading to ‘depletion through social reproduction’ (Rai et al, 2014).

When corporate harms impact on workers and communities, family members are often required to provide caring labour for those directly affected.

However, the consequential harms of depletion are generally invisible within the law and uncompensated. In assessing the United Nations’ business and human rights framework, we argue that the international legal regime must take account of social reproductive work and its consequent harms.

Labels:
business_and_human_rights, depletion, harms, law, social_reproduction,


Tuesday 28 July 2020

In search of employment: Tackling youth homelessness and unemployment

an article by Jo Axe, Elizabeth Childs and KathleenManion (Royal Roads University, Victoria, BC, Canada) published Children and Youth Services Review Volume 113 (June 2020)

Highlights

  • Employment is an important, yet sometimes overlooked, aspect of assisting vulnerable youth in moving to independence.
  • Understanding the multiple perspectives of the avenues into, and out of, homelessness for young people helps ground effective supported employment programs.
  • Strong resilient partnerships that bridge across employment, housing and support provide a better foundation for programs that can foster participant success and a reciprocal success for the community and workplaces they live and work in.
  • Communicating the expectations of participants and partners fosters smoother processes.
  • Capturing the success of a supported employment program requires careful tracking of the unique value-add they bring to their participants, their employers and their communities.

Abstract

At a time when homelessness, inequality and poverty plague Canadian society, an organisation in Whistler, British Columbia has been working for over 20 years to combat some of the associated issues faced by vulnerable youth.

This multi-year research project explored one of the programs offered by the organisation with the intent of gaining an understanding of the short- and long-term impact, the future requirements for sustainability and growth, and the alignment of the program to local and regional needs.

Through a series of focus groups, qualitative data was collected and, while the focus of the research project fell across the identified program foci of housing, employment, participant experience, and support, this article focuses specifically on the findings related to employment.

The five themes that were identified in the data collected included:

  • participants’ context,
  • processes to support accountability,
  • contributors to success,
  • challenges, and
  • participants’ suggestions for improvement.

Across these themes and sub-themes, it was clear that stable employment is a necessary component of a comprehensive program that supports youth as they build resilience and combat homelessness.

Labels:
youth_homelessness, youth_employment, youth_unemployment, supportive_employment, reciprocity,


Gender differences in the union wage premium? A comparative case study

an article by Alex Bryson (University College London, UK), Harald Dale-Olsen (Institutt for samfunnsforskning, Norway) and Kristine Nergaard (Fafo, Norway) published in European Journal of Industrial Relations Volume 26 Issue 2 (June 2020)

Abstract

Trade unions have changed from being male dominated to majority-female organisations.

We use linked employer-employee surveys for Norway and Britain to examine whether, in keeping with a median voter model, the gender shift in union membership has resulted in differential wage returns to unionisation among men and women.

In Britain, while only women receive a union wage premium, only men benefit from the increased bargaining power of their union as indicated by workplace union density. In Norway, however, both men and women receive a union wage premium in male-dominated workplaces; but where the union is female dominated, women benefit more than men.

The findings suggest British unions continue to adopt a paternalistic attitude to representing their membership, in contrast to their more progressive counterparts in Norway.

Labels:
unions, gender, wages,


Friday 24 July 2020

Multiple‐systems analysis for the quantification of modern slavery: classical and Bayesian approaches

an article by Bernard W. Silverman (University of Nottingham, UK) published in Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Statistics in Society Series A Volume 183 Issue 3 (June 2020)

Summary

Multiple‐systems estimation is a key approach for quantifying hidden populations such as the number of victims of modern slavery.

The UK Government published an estimate of 10,000–13,000 victims, constructed by the present author, as part of the strategy leading to the Modern Slavery Act 2015. This estimate was obtained by a stepwise multiple‐systems method based on six lists.

Further investigation shows that a small proportion of the possible models give rather different answers, and that other model fitting approaches may choose one of these.

Three data sets collected in the field of modern slavery, together with a data set about the death toll in the Kosovo conflict, are used to investigate the stability and robustness of various multiple‐systems‐estimate methods.

The crucial aspect is the way that interactions between lists are modelled, because these can substantially affect the results. Model selection and Bayesian approaches are considered in detail, in particular to assess their stability and robustness when applied to real modern slavery data. A new Markov chain Monte Carlo Bayesian approach is developed; overall, this gives robust and stable results at least for the examples considered.

The software and data sets are freely and publicly available to facilitate wider implementation and further research.

Full text (PDF 46pp)

Labels:
hidden_populations, human_trafficking, Markov_chain Monte_Carlo_methods, public_policy, thresholding,

Hazel’s comment:
I have definitely not kept up with manipulation of statistics since I retired but this looks as though useful insights into the scale of modern slavery have been achieved.



 

Tuesday 21 July 2020

10 for Today starts in Shakespeare's Athens and actually ends back in Greece (not deliberately)

Timon of Athens: A Short Plot Summary of Shakespeare’s Play
via Interesting Literature

Of all Shakespeare’s plays, Timon of Athens is perhaps the most easy to summarise in terms of its plot; certainly it’s up there in the top five of his plays with the simplest plot which can be summarised in just a few sentences. So we’ll keep the following plot summary brief.
Continue reading

==============================
Piri Reis Map - How Could a 16th Century Map Show Antarctica Without Ice?
via Ancient Origins by Beth
Piri Reis Map
The Piri Reis Map. Credit: Mehmetilker / Adobe Stock
On October 9, 1929, a German theologian named Gustav Adolf Deissmann was cataloguing items in the Topkapi Palace library in Istanbul when he happened across a curious parchment located among some disregarded material. On the gazelle skin parchment was a map, now referred to as the Piri Reis map .
The map was drawn and signed by Turkish cartographer Hagji Ahmed Muhiddin Piri , aka Piri Reis, and is dated to 1513 AD. Reis was an admiral in the Turkish navy, an experienced sailor, and a cartographer, who claimed to have used 20 source maps and charts to construct the map, including 8 Ptolemaic maps, 4 Portuguese maps, an Arabic map, and a map by Christopher Columbus.
Continue reading

==============================
Lithium: A Doctor, A Drug, And A Breakthrough
via 3 Quarks Daily by Morgan Meis by A J Lees at Literary Review:
Lithium is a silvery-white metal that is so light it can float on water and so soft it can be cut with a butter knife. Along with hydrogen and helium it was produced during the Big Bang and so formed the universe before the emergence of the galaxies. It is employed to harden glass and to thicken grease, but its best-known industrial use is in the manufacture of rechargeable batteries. Lithium salts are found in considerable quantities in brine and igneous granite and the element is present in trace quantities in the human body. Lithium is also one of the few metals – along with platinum for cancer, gold for rheumatoid arthritis and bismuth for dyspepsia – that are used as medicines.
Continue reading

==============================
10 of the Best Poems about Graveyards
via Interesting Literature
Death looms large in poetry, from epitaphs to poems of grief over the loss of a loved one. And, of course, there’s a long-standing tradition of religious or sacred poems. But what about churchyards, graveyards, and cemeteries – those spaces around the church filled with the dead, with epitaphs by turns moving and cringeworthy, with yew trees and with flowers brought in memory of the deceased? Below we attempt to introduce ten of the very greatest poems about churchyards.
Continue reading

==============================
The fever tree
via The Royal Society Repository blog by Melody Bishop

Cinchona of St Lucia: plate 19 from ‘An account of a new species of the Bark-tree, found in the Island of St Lucia’ by George Davidson, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, vol.74 part 2 (1784), pp.452-456.
In summer 2018, I was the sole Undergraduate Research Assistant for a project entitled ‘The Fever Tree’. This initiative, jointly run by Dr Marc Etherington (Physics) and Dr David Lowther (History) at Durham University and sponsored by the Hatfield Trust, aimed to understand the changing interest in quinine and divergent routes of study throughout the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
My main responsibility during this internship was to transcribe nineteenth-century scientific correspondence. The aim was to analyse how the study of quinine – a compound derived from the bark of the cinchona tree and the key component of tonic water – changed over time, ultimately resulting in quinine’s reputation as a valuable antimalarial and fluorescence standard.
Continue reading

==============================
Be My Matelotage! The Civil Union of 17th Century Pirates
via Ancient Origins by B.B. Wagner
Matelotage is the marriage / civil union of two male pirates. Source: rdrgraphe / Adobe Stock.
Matelotage is the marriage / civil union of two male pirates. Source: rdrgraphe / Adobe Stock.
Love strikes hard like the broadsiding from a warship, leaving both splinters and buckshot in one’s heart. When it hits, there's nothing anyone can do but accept the bombardment with both arms open. It can happen with friends, co-workers, and even with 17th-century Caribbean pirates . The word 'matelotage’ carried many different meanings, but in the island of Tortuga, matelotage meant the civil union and sexual relationship between two pirate men.
In 1645, the French-controlled island of Tortuga was a safe haven for privateers and buccaneers alike. Tortuga was also a sanctuary for those who wished to have matelotage, the civil union of two male pirates.
Continue reading
This is quite a long read but I found it very interesting. It told me about things I had not previously known.

==============================
How archives helped solve a family mystery
via The National Archives Blog by Kerri Ramsay
Like many of us who find ourselves working at The National Archives, I have a passion for both mysteries and social history. This is the story of how I solved a family mystery of my own – of who really was my estranged great-grandfather? – with a little help from some historical documents.
Robert John Davidson in a locket pendant photograph
Robert John Davidson in a locket pendant photograph
I began my investigation armed with a few random facts that had been passed down through the years. I knew that his name was Robert John Davidson; that he had been married with children to a lady named Catherine; that he was an excellent horse rider; that he had served in the Great War with the Lovat’s Scouts regiment; and that he was buried on the Rothiemurchus estate in Scotland. Finally, perhaps less appealingly, there was the rumour that he had been seeing another woman at the same time as my great-grandmother!
Continue reading

==============================
An Interesting Character Study: Lady Macbeth
via Interesting LIterature
Lady Macbeth is widely regarded as one of the most villainous female characters in all of English literature, and perhaps Shakespeare’s most cold-hearted female character. Not only does she urge her husband to murder their King for no other reason than heartless ambition, she also states that she would dash out her own baby’s brains rather than lose her courage for such a regicidal act.
Continue reading

==============================
The Intelligence of Plants
via Arts and Letters Daily: Cody Delistraty at the Paris Review

MIGUEL RIO BRANCO, UNTITLED, TOKYO, 2008  © MIGUEL RIO BRANCO
What if plants are smarter than we think – a lot smarter?
A few years ago, Monica Gagliano, an associate professor in evolutionary ecology at the University of Western Australia, began dropping potted Mimosa pudicas. She used a sliding steel rail that guided them to six inches above a cushioned surface, then let them fall. The plant, which is leafy and green with pink-purple flower heads, is commonly known as a “shameplant” or a “touch-me-not” because its leaves fold inward when it’s disturbed. In theory, it would defend itself against any attack, indiscriminately perceiving any touch or drop as an offence and closing itself up.
The first time Gagliano dropped the plants – fifty-six of them – from the measured height, they responded as expected. But after several more drops, fewer of them closed. She dropped each of them sixty times, in five-second intervals. Eventually, all of them stopped closing. She continued like this for twenty-eight days, but none of them ever closed up again. It was only when she bothered them differently – such as by grabbing them – that they reverted to their usual defence mechanism.
Continue reading

==============================
Ancient Greek Physician Hippocrates and the Medical Revolution
via Ancient Origins by Sarah P Young
Hippocrates Statue and Dooley Hospital Door. Source: CC BY 2.0
Hippocrates Statue and Dooley Hospital Door 
Classical Greece is considered by many to be the birthplace of modern Western civilization. The ancient Greeks made astounding progress in a huge number of areas - from politics and governing to religious practice and philosophical thought. The impact the Hellenic culture had is still felt throughout the world today.
Archimedes, Pythagoras, Plato, Aristotle, Socrates, Homer – the list of figures from ancient Greece who have left their mark on the world today is astounding and the innovations and principles they pioneered surround us in our day-to-day lives.
One ancient Greek whose influence is still felt the world over is Hippocrates – a physician who is widely known as the father of modern or clinical medicine. Medicine and healthcare had been practised for thousands of years. The healing properties of things such as willow bark, cannabis, and poppies were recognised and taken advantage of long before the rise of the Classical World.
Continue reading

Monday 20 July 2020

Towards a Criminology of the Domestic

an article by Pamela Davies and Michael Rowe (Northumbria University, UK) published in The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice Volume 59 Issue 2 (June 2020)

Abstract

Criminology has paid insufficient attention to the ‘domestic’ arena, as a locale that is being reconfigured through technological and social developments in ways that require us to reconsider offending and victimisation.

This article addresses this lacuna.

We take up Campbell's (2016) challenge that criminology needs to develop more sophisticated models of place and space, particularly in relation to changing patterns of consumption and leisure activity and the opportunities to offend in relation to these from within the domestic arena.


Full text (PDF 15pp)

Labels:
domestic, home, relational, technological_and_social_change,


Sunday 19 July 2020

Party government and policy responsiveness. Evidence from three parliamentary democracies

an article by Dimiter Toshkov (Leiden University, The Netherlands), Lars Mäder (University of Copenhagen, Denmark) and Anne Rasmussen (Leiden University, The Netherlands; University of Copenhagen, Denmark) published in Journal of Public Policy Volume 40 Issue 2 (June 2020)

Abstract

Does party government moderate the responsiveness of public policy to public opinion?

Analysing a new dataset, we examine whether the ability of governments to respond to the public on 306 specific policy issues in Denmark, Germany and the UK is affected by the extent of coalition conflict and by the fit of the considered policy changes with the government preferences.

We find a systematic but relatively weak positive impact of public support on the likelihood and speed of policy change. Contrary to expectations, a higher number of coalition partners are not associated with fewer policy changes nor with weaker responsiveness to public opinion.

We also find no evidence that responsiveness to public opinion is necessarily weaker for policy changes that go against the preferences of the government. Rather, it appears that public and government support for policy change are substitute resources.

Full text (PDF 19pp)

Labels:
coalition_government, legislative_decision-making, party_government, policy_change, policy_responsiveness, political_parties, public_opinion,


Moments of alignment between devolved political ideology and policy design: the case of Wales

an article by Sioned Pearce, Christala Sophocleous, Helen Blakely and Eva Elliott (Cardiff University) published in People, Place and Policy Volume 14 Issue 1 (2020)

Abstract

The devolution of power and responsibility from central to sub national levels of governance over the past half century marks a paradigm shift in forces shaping social policy across much of Western Europe. Scholarship in this field is often concerned with a binary analysis of before and after the advent of devolution, with insufficient attention paid to transitory changes over time.

Through attention to Wales’ flagship community regeneration programme, Communities First, a striking instance of divergent devolved social policy, we highlight the need to attend to the dynamics of devolution across time.

Drawing on empirical data charting the programme’s conception, implementation, evolution, distortion and eventual demise, we argue that a moment of alignment between ideology and policy design was visible at conception but eroded over 16 years, as the programme increasingly came to bear the hallmarks of neoliberalism.

Using this case study, we consider the extent to which newly devolved states can implement ideological policy visions that resist the restraints put upon sub-state governance on the one hand and forces of central state ideologies and logics on the other.

Full text (PDF 18pp) 

Labels:
devolution, social_policy, community, ideology, policy_design,


Friday 17 July 2020

Is Retirement a Crisis for Men? Class and Adjustment to Retirement

an article by Ilkka Pietilä and Hanna Ojala (University of Tampere, Finland) and Toni Calasanti and Neal King (Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA) published in Men and Masculinities Volume 23 Issue 2 (June 2020)

Abstract

Because paid work is taken to be central to manhood, scholarly and popular discourse have characterised retirement as presenting a “crisis of masculinity.” However, such a crisis is not borne out by research, perhaps because scholars have not considered how class might shape masculinities and thus expectations and experiences of retirement.

Using data obtained from interviews with Finnish metal workers and engineers who are either approaching retirement or recently retired, we ask whether
  1. this crisis discourse is reflected in their retirement expectations,
  2. it matches their actual experiences of retirement, and
  3. retirement disrupts the masculinities of some class groups more than others.
We find evidence of this retirement crisis discourse in our respondents’ views of retirement, but not in their actual experiences, belying the homogeneity of masculinity implied by it. Class shapes both the perceived content of crises and the actual retirement experiences.

Labels:
Finland, masculinities, middle-class, respectability, working-class,


Wednesday 15 July 2020

Information and Communication Technologies as Contentious Repertoire

an article by Jun Liu (University of Copenhagen, Denmark) published in European Journal of Sociology / Archives Européennes de Sociologie Volume 61 Issue 1 (April 2020)

Abstract

This study advances an original theoretical framework to understand the deployment of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) in political contention.

It argues that we should not look only at the use of ICTs in contention, as technologies are not “born” to be used in and for political activism. Rather, people appropriate and manoeuvre technologies – some but not others – for such purposes, in specific contexts.

This study proposes a relational understanding of ICT uses in contention, taking into account their technicalities and their sociality, as well as the transformation and actualisation that occurs between them. It suggests that an investigation necessitates the perception of communication technologies as a repertoire of contention on the basis of affordances that structure the possibilities of the use of technology.

The study further presents an application of the framework in cases of protests in mainland China.

Through fieldwork and in-depth interviews, this study indicates that the choice of (certain functions of) mobile phones as protest repertoire derives from a confluence of
a. a given social group’s habitus of media use that manifests particular affordances, and
b. the learned experience of the contested means of the past in official mass communication.

It concludes that what people do and do not do with ICTs in political contention is significantly shaped by affordances and habitus, thereby revealing the dynamics behind repertoire selection and constraint.

Labels:
information_and_communication_technologies, ICTs, political_contention, affordance, repertoire_of_contention, habitus, affordance,


Evidence based social media use: an exploratory UK investigation into residents’ perceptions of police Facebook use

an article by Ashley Cartwright (University of Huddersfield, UK) and Chloe Shaw (Leeds Beckett University, UK) published in Safer Communities Volume 19 Issue 2 (2020)

Abstract

Purpose
Social media is an integral part of modern society and is used by billions of people worldwide. In a policing context, police services are starting to use social media platforms to interact with their communities. However, academic literature is lagging regarding the effectiveness of police use of social media. The purpose of this study is to gather public perceptions regarding the police’s use of social media particularly the use of Facebook.

Design/methodology/approach
The study administered a cross sectional survey recruiting participants who are policed by one of the larger police services in England and Wales. A total of 294 respondents completed the survey providing their views on their police service’s use of social media.

Findings
The results of the present study provide overwhelming support for the police’s use of social media by the public, with most respondents actively following their local police service’s social media accounts. The study additionally provides a number of important findings in relation to the preferences of the public with regards to their police service’s use of Facebook.

Practical implications
The findings presented here provide police services with an insight into how to implement an evidenced-based approach to their social media activity.

Originality/value
The present study takes an alternative approach to understanding the effectiveness of police social media use by simply asking residents, an approach not used in this area of policing research to date.

Labels:
social_media, Facebook, police, public_perceptions, survey, evidence-based,


Wednesday 8 July 2020

The practice of responsible research and innovation in “climate engineering”

an article by Sean Low (Institute for Advanced Sustainability Studies, Potsdam, Germany; Utrecht University, the  Netherlands) and Holly Jean Buck (University of California, Los Angeles, USA) published in WIRES Climate Change Volume 11 Issue 3 (May/June 2020)

Abstract

Sunlight reflection and carbon removal proposals for “climate engineering” (CE) confront governance challenges that many emerging technologies face: their futures are uncertain, and by the time one can discern their shape or impacts, vested interests may block regulation, and publics are often left out of decision‐making about them.

In response to these challenges, “responsible research and innovation” (RRI) has emerged as a framework to critique and correct for technocratic governance of emerging technologies, and CE has emerged as a prime case of where it can be helpfully applied.

However, a critical lens is rarely applied to RRI itself.

In this review, we first survey how RRI thinking has already been applied to both carbon removal and sunlight reflection methods for climate intervention.

We examine how RRI is employed in four types of activities: Assessment processes and reports, principles and protocols for research governance, critical mappings of research, and deliberative and futuring engagements.

Drawing upon this review, we identify tensions in RRI practice, including whether RRI forms or informs choices, the positionalities of RRI practitioners, and ways in which RRI activities enable or disable particular climate interventions.

Finally, we recommend that RRI should situate CE within the long arc of sociotechnical proposals for addressing climate change, more actively connect interrogations of the knowledge economy with reparative engagements, include local or actor‐specific contexts, design authoritative assessments grounded in RRI, and go beyond treating critique and engagement as “de facto” governance.

Visual Abstract

Responsible research and innovation (RRI) has been posed as a means to rethink, critique and reshape technocratic and solution‐oriented research and development into global climate engineering techniques—but is RRI fulfilling its potential?

image

Full text (PDF 17pp)

Labels:
assessments, climate_engineering, governance, research_practices, responsible_research and_innovation,


What is mindreading?

an article by Shannon Spaulding (Oklahoma State University, USA) published in WIRES Cognitive Science Volume 11 Issue 3 (May/June 2020)

Abstract

Theory of mind, also known as mindreading, refers to our ability to attribute mental states to agents in order to make sense of and interact with other agents. Recently, theorists in this literature have advanced a broad conception of mindreading.

In particular, psychologists and philosophers have examined how we attribute knowledge, intention, mentalistically loaded stereotypes, and personality traits to others. Moreover, the diversity of our goals in a social interaction – precision, efficiency, self/in‐group protection – generates diversity in the mindreading processes we employ.

Finally, the products of mindreading are varied, as well.

We produce different sorts of mindreading explanations depending on our epistemic goals and the situational context.

In this article, I piece together these different strands of research to present a broad conception of mindreading that is complex, messy, and interesting.

Visual Abstract

Mindreading broadly construed.
image

Labels:
explanation, mindreading, stereotypes, theory_of_mind, traits,


Tuesday 7 July 2020

‘Once more, with feeling,’ said the robot: AI, the end of work and the rise of emotional economies

an article by Roger Patulny, Natasa Lazarevic and Vern Smith (University of Wollongong, Australia) published in Emotions and Society Volume 2 Number 1 (May 2020)

Abstract

This article calls for a new research agenda into ‘emotional economies’, or economies increasingly characterised by the creation, extraction and exploitation of emotional products and labour, enabled by and embedded in rapid advances in technological and digital-media systems.

We base this concept and call on a literature review linking technological automation, the future of work and emotions.

Our review finds that:
  1. many existing studies – whether predicting dystopian end-of-work mass unemployment, or utopian complementarities between humans, machines and digital platforms – are technologically determinist in nature, and do not account for the roles of culture, society, government, business and education in the machine–human–emotion interface;
  2. despite this, there is evidence that technology will replace many existing forms of human labour, leaving only technologically irreplaceable emotion-based soft-skill service work (and emotional labour) for humans to perform;
  3. there is an outside chance (in some literature) that technology and AIs will replace even emotional labour, though we argue this is unlikely for many years;
  4. the increasing centrality of emotional industries, emotional data and emotional labour to work, digital platforms and media-imagery will likely lead to emotions becoming vital commodities, central to the economies of the future.
The article concludes with an urgent call for a new research agenda on emotional economies to elaborate on private/public intersections between work, economy and emotions that soberly engage with the future while challenging technologically determinist assumptions that underpin populist depictions of the end of work.

Labels:
artificial_intelligence, AI, automation, emotion, emotion_management, emotional_labour, future_of_work, gig_work, technological_change, work,


Monday 6 July 2020

Evidence-based policy, knowledge from experience and validity

an article by Jennifer Smith-Merry (University of Sydney, Australia) published in Evidence and Policy: A Journal of Research, Debate and Practice Volume 16 Number 2 (May 2020)

Abstract

Evidence-based policy has at its foundation a set of ideas about what makes evidence valid so that it can be trusted in the creation of policy. This validity is frequently conceptualised in terms of rigour deriving from scientific studies which adhere to highly structured processes around data collection, analysis and inscription.

In comparison, the knowledge gained from lived experience, while viewed as important for ensuring that policy meets the needs of the people it is trying to serve, is characterised by its tacit nature, unstructure and difficulty in transferring from one actor to another.

Validity of experiential knowledge in policy arises from the connection of policy knowledge to the lived experience of individuals.

This paper considers validity in this context through exploring four modes in which experiential knowledge is currently utilised within policy. The tensions surrounding validity in the policy context find resolution through the development of a situated notion of validity decoupled from structural rigour and recoupled to context.

Labels:
coproduction, evidence-based_policy, experiential_knowledge, interpretive_policy_analysis, policy, validity,




Sunday 5 July 2020

Understanding the impact and value of temporary public art sculpture trails

an article by John Thompson and John Day (University of Huddersfield, UK) published in Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit Volume 35 Issue 3 (May 2020)

Abstract

Temporary public art sculpture trails (T-Pasts) have been used for over 20 years around the world to fulfil a number of objectives. They can help to generate revenue for host towns and cities; they can contribute to place branding; they can provide entertainment for residents and visitors; and they can raise funds for designated charitable causes.

They typically feature object characters that have a relevance for the host place and they invariably utilise the same operational model.

They receive significant local publicity and various claims are made concerning their economic, social and aesthetic impact. But there is a case to be made that they are ‘hidden in plain sight’ as some people will walk or drive past exhibits without ever seeing them.

In this article, we track the history of T-Pasts, categorise them into different types, examine their value for different stakeholders, discuss their various impacts and offer a conceptual impact model.

We conclude the article with a discussion that contextualises T-Pasts in relevant themes, including place enabling and place building, and also the significance of the temporary element.

Labels:
cultural_impact, place_and_space, place_branding, place_building, place_enabling, place_promotion, public_art, sculpture_trails, social_impact,


Saturday 4 July 2020

Trade union strategies against precarious work: Common trends and sectoral divergence in the EU

an article by Maarten Keune (Universiteit van Amsterdam, The Netherlands) and Marcello Pedaci (Università di Teramo, Italy) published in European Journal of Industrial Relations Volume 26 Issue 2 (June 2020)

Abstract

We present comparative research on precarious work and trade union strategies in three sectors (construction, industrial cleaning, temporary agency work) across seven European countries.

Specific sectors have a profile of precarious work that is remarkably similar across countries, originating from similar employer strategies and work organisations. This results in unions facing comparable challenges concerning precarious work at sectoral level and developing comparable sectoral strategies to combat precarious work.

The success of these strategies depends to a large extent on the available power resources. Between sectors within single countries, we observe some similarities but also very substantial differences in their institutional configuration and in actors’ constellations, power resources and repertoires of action.

National institutional contexts seem much less significant than often assumed.

Full text (PDF 18pp)

Labels:
Europe, industrial_relations, labour_market, non-standard_forms_of_employment, precarious_work, sectors, trade_unions,


Thursday 2 July 2020

What’s fair? Preferences for tax progressivity in the wake of the financial crisis

an article by Julian Limberg (European University Institute, Italy) published in Journal of Public Policy Volume 40 Issue 2 (June 2020)

Abstract

Progressive taxation is an effective redistributive tool in times of growing inequality. However, like all public policies, an increase in tax progressivity is unlikely if it lacks popular demand.

Has the financial crisis affected the demand for progressive taxation?

Building on research that has identified fairness beliefs as the main factor pushing for taxes on the rich, I argue that the Great Recession and states’ reactions to it have caused a general shift in tax policy preferences.

As a consequence, demand for tax progressivity is higher in crisis countries. Multilevel analyses using survey data for 32 countries show support for my argument. These findings have important implications for our understanding of the politics of redistribution in the 21st century.

Full text (PDF 23pp)

Labels:
fairness, inequality, preferences, redistribution, taxation,


Wednesday 1 July 2020

A preliminary investigation of universal mental health screening practices in schools

an article by Brandon J. Wood (University of Toledo, USA) and Terry McDaniel (Indiana State University, Terre Haute, USA) published in Children and Youth Services Review Volume 112 (May 2020)

Highlights
  • 98.8% of schools sampled are not actively conducting universal mental health screening (UMHS).
  • Most principals (74.6%) reported a moderate or extreme level of interest in conducting UMHS.
  • An overwhelming number (74.6%) of principals possess minimal or no knowledge about UMHS.
Abstract

Many school-aged children possessing or displaying characteristics of a mental health disorder go unidentified and untreated (Flisher et al., 1997; Merikangas et al., 2010; Ringel and Sturm, 2001).

One supported approach, within an educational setting, to improve identification of children presenting mental health concerns is universal mental health screening (UMHS; Glover and Albers, 2007). Using survey methodology, the current study sought to build upon previous research by investigating the proportion of schools currently conducting UMHS and exploring barriers and other factors influencing the conducting of UMHS within schools.

Despite its widespread support, nearly every Indiana school principal in the current study (n = 245) reported that their school does not conduct UMHS. A lack of access to and funding for mental health screeners were the two most commonly reported reasons why principals sampled suggested that their school does not conduct UMHS.

Without the increased adoption and implementation of preventative, proactive practices, such as the conducting of UMHS in schools, significant improvements in the identification and subsequent intervention or treatment of children and adolescents demonstrating mental health concerns may remain unrealised.

Labels:
mental_health, children, adolescents, schools, prevention, Universal_Screening,

Hazel’s comment:

I knew nothing about screening for mental health issues in schools but it certainly seemed, on the surface at least, to be “a good thing” so I went surfing down the rabbit hole of Internet search.

And found some items that might interest you if you have got this far. The first two are from the USA, the third is from the UK.

Universal Mental Health Screening in Pediatric Primary Care: A Systematic Review (2013)

The case for universal mental health screening in schools (2019)

Bring in universal mental health checks in schools (2013)
I wish, oh how I wish, that mental health checks had been in place when I was young and even more do I wish that they could be in place in all schools.


Contesting imaginaries in the Australian city: Urban planning, public storytelling and the implications for climate change

an article by Emily Potter (Deakin University, Australia) published in Urban Studies Volume 57 Issue 7 (May 2020)

Abstract

In Australia, environmental degradation goes hand in hand with exclusionary and mono-vocal tactics of place-making.

This article argues that dominant cultural imaginaries inform material and discursive practices of place-making with significant consequence for diverse, inclusive and climate change-responsive urban environments.

Urban planning in the modern global city commonly deploys imaginaries in line with neoliberal logics, and this article takes a particular interest in the impact of this on Indigenous Australians, whose original dispossession connects through to current Indigenous urban experiences of exclusion which are set to intensify in the face of increasing climate change.

The article explores what urban resilience means in this context, focusing on a case study of urban development in Port Adelaide, South Australia, and broadens the question of dispossession through the forces of global capital to potentially all of humanity in the Anthropocene.

Labels:
built_environment, culture/arts/creativity, colonisation_displacement/gentrification, history/heritage/memory, neoliberalism, public_space, resilience,