Human Stakeholders and the Use of Animals in Drug Development

an article by Lisa A. Kramer (University of Toronto, Canada) and Ray Greek (Americans for MedicalAdvancement, Goleta, CA) published in Business and Society Review Volume 123 Issue 1 (Spring 2018)

Abstract

Pharmaceutical firms seek to fulfill their responsibilities to stakeholders by developing drugs that treat diseases.

We evaluate the social and financial costs of developing new drugs relative to the realized benefits and find the industry falls short of its potential. This is primarily due to legislation‐mandated reliance on animal test results in early stages of the drug development process, leading to a mere 10 percent success rate for new drugs entering human clinical trials.

We cite hundreds of biomedical studies from journals including Nature, Science, and the Journal of the American Medical Association to show animal modeling is ineffective, misleading to scientists, unable to prevent the development of dangerous drugs, and prone to prevent the development of useful drugs.

Legislation still requires animal testing prior to human testing even though the pharmaceutical sector has better options that were unavailable when animal modeling was first mandated.

We propose that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Congress should work together to abolish regulations and policies that require animal use. Doing so will benefit pharmaceutical industry stakeholders, including patients whose health depends on drugs and the many people who rely on the financial well‐being of pharmaceutical firms.

Full text (PDF 56pp) Note: The PDF uses a large font!

---