‘On the wet side of the womb’: The construction of ‘mothers’ in anti-abortion activism in England and Wales

an article by Pam Lowe and Sarah-Jane Page (Aston University, UK) published in European Journal of Women's Studies Volume 26 Issue 2 (May 2019)

Abstract

Across the UK, there has been an increase in anti-abortion activism outside abortion clinics. The activism deployed includes explicitly religious activities such as ‘prayerful witnessing’ and ‘pavement counselling’, which aim to discourage women from entering clinics.

This article stems from a wider ethnographic study of public activism over abortion to determine what claims about motherhood are being made within these debates.

Two arguments are presented.

First, how women’s role as mothers is central and essentialised in anti-abortion discourses, with the body of the mother often disappearing as activists seek to erode the distinction between a foetus and a baby by constructing pregnancy as a foetal environment. Motherhood is constructed as ‘natural’ and sacred, therefore abortion must be damaging because it destroys women’s ‘natural’ position.

Second, the article argues that although the activists’ arguments are always religiously framed, their activism takes place in a largely secular context, meaning that they have to find ways of appealing to secular audiences.

This leads to a complex interrelationship between secular and religious discourses, where theological viewpoints sit alongside ‘scientific’ claims to buttress activists’ views.

This article explores how the presence and absence of mothers within activists’ narratives is due to the tensions between religiously based understandings of motherhood, and the need to appeal to a secular audience.

---