Why are teacher recommendations at the transition from primary to secondary education socially biased? A mixed-methods research

an article by Simon Boone and Mieke Van Houtte (Ghent University, Belgium) published in British Journal of Sociology of Education Volume 34 Issue 1 (January 2013)

Abstract

The consequences of educational differentiation have been at the centre of research in sociology of education during the past decades.

Processes of educational allocation have, however, received much less attention.

Despite the fact that research has shown that teacher recommendations in France and Germany are partly determined by pupils’ social background, studies that inquire into the causes of this social bias seem to be virtually inexistent.

This study aims to examine whether teacher recommendations at the transition from primary to secondary education in Flanders (northern, Dutch-speaking part of Belgium) are also socially biased, and if so what causes these differentials in advice, using a mixed-methods design.

We found the advice given by primary school teachers to be partly determined by pupils’ social background. Analysis of the qualitative data suggests that teachers tend to evaluate pupils from low socio-economic status backgrounds less positively, due to their emphasis on specific pupil characteristics.

---