Thursday 28 November 2019

Theory of mind in animals: Current and future directions

an article by Christopher Krupenye and Josep Call (University of St Andrews, UK) published in WIREs Cognitive Science Volume 10 Issue 6 (November/December 2019)

Visual Abstract

Forty years of research has sought to determine whether nonhuman animals, like this bonobo, have a theory of mind.

image

Abstract

Theory of mind (ToM; a.k.a., mind‐reading, mentalizing, mental‐state attribution, and perspective‐taking) is the ability to ascribe mental states, such as desires and beliefs, to others, and it is central to the unique forms of communication, cooperation, and culture that define our species. As a result, for 40 years, researchers have endeavoured to determine whether ToM is itself unique to humans.

Investigations in other species (e.g., apes, monkeys, corvids) are essential to understand the mechanistic underpinnings and evolutionary origins of this capacity across taxa, including humans.

We review the literature on ToM in nonhuman animals, suggesting that some species share foundational social cognitive mechanisms with humans.

We focus principally on innovations of the last decade and pressing directions for future work. Underexplored types of social cognition have been targeted, including ascription of mental states, such as desires and beliefs, that require simultaneously representing one's own and another's conflicting motives or views of the world.

Ongoing efforts probe the motivational facets of ToM, how flexibly animals can recruit social cognitive skills across cooperative and competitive settings, and appropriate motivational contexts for comparative inquiry.

Finally, novel methodological and empirical approaches have brought new species (e.g., lemurs, dogs) into the lab, implemented critical controls to elucidate underlying mechanisms, and contributed powerful new techniques (e.g., looking‐time, eye‐tracking) that open the door to unexplored approaches for studying animal minds. These innovations in cognition, motivation, and method promise fruitful progress in the years to come, in understanding the nature and origin of ToM in humans and other species.


No comments: