Shaped by place? Young people’s aspirations in disadvantaged neighbourhoods

an article by Keith Kintrea (Social and Political Sciences, University of Glasgow, UK), Ralf St Clair (Faculty of Education, University of Victoria, Victoria, Canada) and Muir Houston (School of Education, University of Glasgow, UK) published in Journal of Youth Studies Volume 18 Issue 5 (2015)

Abstract

This paper aims to better understand the relationship between young people’s aspirations towards education and jobs, and the context in which they are formed, especially to understand better the role of disadvantaged places in shaping young people’s aspirations.

Policy makers maintain that disadvantaged areas are associated with low aspirations and there is support for this position from academic work on neighbourhood effects and local labour markets, but evidence is slim.

Using a two-stage survey of young people in disadvantaged settings in three British cities, the paper provides new data on the nature of young peoples’ aspirations, how they change during the teenage years, and how they relate to the places where they are growing up.

The findings are that aspirations are very high and, overall, they do not appear to be depressed in relation to the jobs available in the labour market either by the neighbourhood context or by young people’s perceptions of local labour markets. However, there are significant differences between the pattern of aspirations and how they change over time in the three locations.

The paper then challenges assumptions in policy and in the literature that disadvantaged places equal low aspirations and suggests that understanding how aspirations are formed requires a nuanced approach to the nexus of class, ethnicity and institutional influences within local areas.

---